The Ultimatum
Get Spiller or Dez or trade down and get more picks. It's pretty much that simple. When the Giants won SB 42 they were a team on the rise, that looked like they had a large championship window. Two years later, that's questionable. With a strong draft they can get back to the top. With a poor draft, we're looking at more diminishing returns. Let's hit a homerun in the first, then find gems on Friday and Saturday. I used to expect this from Jerry Reese, but all the McClain talk as got me spooked. Go Giants!
posted by Kalel9 @ 10:13 AM
10 Comments:
I thought the NFP was supposed to be a good publication?
I agree Phil. If McClain was a Patrick Willis type, I would be very excited. The film I've seen shows McClain with some woeful tackling technique. I hope the McClain talk is all a smokescreen. Love to have Spiller or Bryant.
If we trade up for McClain, I will blast the Giants for that pick at least until he makes a probowl, which he won't.
If you had to choose one scenario: Trade up for Spiller or pick McClain at 15?
Trade up for Spiller gets my vote, but I agree with Phil too much depth in the draft to give up anything unless we get more picks in return
I would trade up for Spiller, but the situation you present is like choosing between paying the kidnappers or losing the kid.
I just wanted to get a sense about how negatively you evaluate McClain.
I wouldnt say he will never make a probowl, with how many people drop out of it I could see Mcclain being a top 15 ILB in the NFL which is all you need to make the pro bowl
He's an ILB not and MLB. I could see him making it in a 3-4,he's just a lousy fit for a 4-3.
Schefter tweeted we are interested in moving up...
Post a Comment
<< Home